The Ongoing 'Patty War'

E-mail Print PDF
The Jamaican Community in the US North East of which I am the Jamaica Diaspora Advisory Member, is completely dumbfounded by the recent statements/protest of JMA President Azan regarding the importation of Caribbean Food Delight’s patty into Jamaica.

Jamaica has no monopoly on patty and like Minister Samuda explained, is a part of an international community that participates in “free trade”. Recently I stayed in a hotel on the north coast and was very disturbed with the absence of “Jamaican Alcoholic beverages” , I never recall hearing Mr. Azan or other “concerned Jamaicans” complain about this.

Ironically Mr. Azan never mentioned that the company he is protesting is owned and operated by a “Patriotic Jamaican” and his family – Mr. Vincent HoSang. Ask all the athletes who have participated in Penn Relays for the past 20 years about Caribbean Delight and the HoSang family, indeed they will tell you sir and all Jamaica that this is the company who feed them and donate on top of this, money to assist in hotel and transportation.  Royal Caribbean is incredibly generous to the Diaspora Community and to charities in Jamaica.  They have donated close to US$1 million in cash and equipment, including a medical mobile that brings health care to thousands in rural Jamaica.  Just recently, they gave US$30,000 to Father Ho Lung to help the poor in Jamaica.

The entire Diaspora community, especially the tri-state area of New York/New Jersey & Connecticut knows who Vinny & Caribbean Food Delight is to the community:

Over 60% of Caribbean Food Delights employees are Jamaican.

Caribbean Food Delights is the largest Jamaican frozen food manufacturer in the United States owned and operated by Jamaicans.

One of the few Jamaican plants inspected by United States Department of Agriculture (USDA).

Caribbean Food Delights is a state-of-the-art plant over 100, 000 sq. ft. on 10 acres.

Six full scholarships were given to six students totaling US$150,000, for the entrepreneurial program at the University of the West Indies in Jamaica.

In 2005, VHFF donated a fully-equipped mobile health clinic worth US$180,000 to Dr. Roy Streete of the Organization for International Development (OID) for the people in Jamaica. Dr. Streete and his team provide free dental and medical services to the less fortunate.

VHFF donated US$250,000 to Father Ho Lung of Missionaries of the Poor to build a chapel in Jamaica. The chapel will all serve another purpose: in the day time, it will be a basic school to educate children in Jamaica.

Caribbean Food Delights serve over 400 student athletes from Jamaica at the Penn Relays for three days and donate $10,000 to help provide accommodations and transportation which they’ve been doing every April since 1994.

In 2004, a donation of $5000 was given towards Hurricane Dean Relief fund.

In 2005, assistance was given to 20 Jamaicans who were affected by Hurricane Rita in Texas by donating $5000.00.

In 2008, the company donated clothes, shoes, food, toiletries and money to Haiti for their Hurricane relief efforts.

Computers were donated to schools in Jamaica.


We in the Diaspora love to give back to our “beloved Jamaica”, but Jamaicans must understand also we are importers as well as exporters and indeed organization like JMA have for years neglected what we can offer, in terms of expertise and investments in their individual companies. I am surprise that following the recent complaint about Trinidad JMA would go this route!

We urge the government to not yield and to our fellow Jamaicans to support  Caribbean Food Delight, because we are positive that profits from this company does indeed circulates in our communities directly and indirectly. This is shortsighted and selfish of Mr. Azan and JMA.

Patrick A Beckford, Jamaica Diaspora Advisory Board Director
US North East,  22 Heinrich Rd, Somerset NJ 08873

Comments  

 
0 #10 Lorna L. 2010-01-22 19:16 I agree with everyone except Oliver. I know the HoSangs are very generous. However you cannot take sand to the beach. Otherwise we all should go down with some patties from foreign on our next vacation so we don\\\'t have to buy it. Quote
 
 
0 #9 Linda 2009-07-22 04:06 I was recently in Jamaica, and tried all the patties there. I was not impressed. I did not like the crust at all. Yes, they should import patties maybe from Toronto where the best patties are made by Jamaicans. Quote
 
 
0 #8 K-Dog 2009-07-13 04:48 Setup a factory in Jamaica and make patties! Your ingredients cannot be 100% Jamaican if you make them outside the country. Let’s see how the Local patty giants - Tastee and Juci respond. Surely they cannot just sit by and watch their market get tapped into. Quote
 
 
0 #7 Lindsay Latham 2009-07-13 03:30 This reminds me of the importation of Transistor radios, Televisions and automobiles into the US from Japan during the 1960s and 1970s. Both the American consumers and auto manufacturers were jarred out of their complacency when they realized that the US did not have a monopoly on the industry. As much as people tried to bad mouth the imported product as inferior as and less than genuine time proved them totally wrong. What was a wakeup call for the US manufacturers to do things different and better went unheeded. We see the consequences today with the major stumbling of the big three. Quote
 
 
0 #6 Esteban Agosto Reid 2009-07-06 09:48 Well said, Mr. Oliver Hunter !! I concur, totally !! Ditto !! Quote
 
 
0 #5 lorraine 2009-07-06 03:26 Is this for real? We are importing the ingredients for patties into Jamaica. Patty is 100% Jamaica. When I go home I do not want imported ingredients in my patty. I am not going to buy patty when I go home. I will just buy what is made in the USA. Quote
 
 
0 #4 Sylbourne Sydial 2009-07-04 10:19 I am completely amazed by this debate. I am a member of the Jamaican community in the UK and find this mind boggling.

How can Jamaica be importing patty. I am hearing different justification why to support importation of patties. One example is that the ingredients are 100% Jamaican. Now think about it we are not just importing patties but also the ingredients.

CFD should be commended for all the work and support they are giving to Jamaica as set out by Patrick Beckford. I echo the view that CFD should establish a factory in Jamaica.

Finally, the question also is this; is it economical for patties to be imported to Jamaica rather than being manufactured in Jamaica?

I may take some ackee and breadfruit back to Jamaica from Brixton when I visit Jamaican next and sell it in Ocho Rios Market.
Quote
 
 
-1 #3 ac 2009-07-04 06:42 If Caribbean delight wants to help Jamaica they should set up a patty factory in Jamaica…it will provide work for Jamaicans and provide needed foreign exchange…our import bill is too high now to be importing something which is originally from here. Take patty from Jamaica …sell as authentic patty made in Jamaica. That might generate more money for Caribbean Delights…or why not go to other Caribbean country. Quote
 
 
0 #2 doreen murdock 2009-07-03 03:07 I commend CFD for giving back but be reasonable, should Jamaica be importing Patties? I am going to take some sea water to Jamaica on my next visit. Quote
 
 
0 #1 Oliver Hunter 2009-07-02 06:56 If people are against imported patties, there is a simple way to register your objection - don't buy one. Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Live Jamaican Radio Streams